nline dating with a niche focus can be extremely appealing — especially for older singles looking for meaningful connections. DateMyAge.com markets itself as just that: a place where mature daters can connect. But user reviews paint a very different picture. In this in-depth analysis, we explore whether DateMyAge is a genuine platform or a sophisticated, profit-driven scheme.
What is DateMyAge.com?
DateMyAge.com is a dating site primarily targeted at older individuals, usually those seeking mature companionship. The platform promises an inclusive, age-focused environment where users can chat, form friendships, or possibly find long-term partners. On its surface, it presents like a typical dating service — but there are several layers to how it operates, especially when it comes to its “pay-per-activity” credit system.
Trust and Legitimacy: Mixed Signals
A Look at Reputation Scores
- According to ScamAdviser, DateMyAge.com has a moderate to good trust score. The site holds a valid SSL certificate and appears to have been in operation for a significant period, which are positive indicators.
- However, Scam Detector rated the site just 54.3 out of 100, calling its legitimacy “questionable” due to risk factors identified in its analysis of 53 data points.
These two assessments together suggest that while DateMyAge.com is not necessarily a front for phishing or malware, users should proceed with caution, especially around financial transactions.
What Real Users Are Saying — A Flood of Criticism
Trustpilot Feedback: Extremely Low Score
On Trustpilot, DateMyAge has an abysmal 1.5 out of 5. Frequent complaints include:
- Loss of credits very quickly.
- Conversations that feel scripted or too perfect.
- High suspicion of fake profiles or AI-generated chat behavior.
- Recurring problems with account cancellation or deletion.
Many users explicitly call out what they believe are bots or paid operators pretending to be other users, designed to hook people into spending more credits.
Sitejabber: Over 300 Negative Reviews
On Sitejabber, DateMyAge has around 335 reviews and rates 1.6 out of 5, clearly skewed toward dissatisfaction. Common themes include:
- Fake profiles: Users mention being bombarded by profiles that look too good to be true.
- Credit card issues: Several claim they were charged after canceling or that billing wasn’t transparent.
- Customer service: Many say that support is unresponsive or ineffective when they raise concerns.
- Pushy credit system: Rather than a flat subscription, messaging and other features cost credits — and they drain fast if you engage.
One reviewer summarized the experience as “a money-driven scam … all of the people look like models … they write as if they used ChatGPT.”
Deep Dive: Fake Profiles, Bots, and AI
One of the loudest and most consistent criticisms revolves around authenticity.
- According to a detailed analysis, the platform may host fake profiles, bots, and even “curated” accounts that don’t represent real, paying users.
- Several users claim they received the same message from multiple “members,” suggesting scripted or automated chat behavior.
- Some profiles reportedly claim to be “curated by a partner” of the site — a red flag often linked to entertainment-focused accounts rather than genuine dating interest.
Overall, the point is consistent: many users believe “active” profiles may not be real people seeking real connections.
Finance
A major source of frustration is the credit-based payment system:
- Pay-per-message: Unlike subscription-based platforms that allow unlimited messaging, DateMyAge charges credits for conversations. Several users report that messaging, video calls, or even seeing certain content burns credits very fast.
- Non-tran: There are reports of users being charged again even after canceling or leaving the site.
- Be: On Reddit, users warn that the platform feels designed to extract money. One user claimed that they were unable to view a received video unless they paid for more credits.Another said they were encouraged to spend more instead of moving the conversation to WhatsApp or another free app.
Re
Reddit threads reveal even more troubling personal stories:
- One user said they were bombarded with messages before even paying, raising immediate red flags about whether the matches were real.
- Another shared that despite asking for a refund, they felt the owners didn’t care about user safety or the financial consequences of the seemingly scripted chats.
- One person claimed they lost $247,000 over 11 months, alleging essential parts of the site operate not to foster real relationships but to sustain a continuous money drain.
- Multiple users note that attempts to exchange personal contact info or meet outside the platform are met with resistance.
Red Flags Summarized
Putting together user reviews, expert analysis, and platform behavior, here are key red flags emerging for DateMyAge:
- Fake or AI-generated profiles: Many users suspect they are chatting with bots or actors, not genuine daters.
- Credit-based system: The pay-per-chat model seems to encourage ongoing spending rather than fostering real connections.
- High price for engagement: Credits deplete quickly, making long conversations expensive.
- Poor cancellation: Some users report trouble deleting their accounts, recurrent billing, or lack of response from support.
- Limited authenticity verification: The verification of profiles is questioned by many — if it’s too easy to create polished, engaging accounts, how real are those people?
Red Flags Summarized
Putting together user reviews, expert analysis, and platform behavior, here are key red flags emerging for DateMyAge:
- Fake or AI-generated profiles: Many users suspect they are chatting with bots or actors, not genuine daters.
- Credit-based system: The pay-per-chat model seems to encourage ongoing spending rather than fostering real connections.
- High price for engagement: Credits deplete quickly, making long conversations expensive.
- Poor cancellation: Some users report trouble deleting their accounts, recurrent billing, or lack of response from support.
- Limited authenticity verification: The verification of profiles is questioned by many — if it’s too easy to create polished, engaging accounts, how real are those people?
What Does DateMyAge Say in Its Defense?
From responses to user criticisms:
- The site claims to enforce profile verification and “compliance checks” to keep the community genuine.
- They argue that their credit model gives flexibility — not everyone needs unlimited messaging, so paying per use can be more cost-effective and safer.
- For users accusing the platform of AI or fake profiles, DateMyAge encourages reporting suspicious accounts to their support team, promising investigation.
Final Value
Based on:
- The overwhelming number of negative user reviews from Trustpilot and Sitejabber
- Reddit user testimonials describing financial loss, scripted messages, and difficulty quitting
- Third-party risk assessments giving only moderate trust ratings
It’s fair to conclude that DateMyAge.com carries substantial risk, especially if you’re expecting a serious dating experience.
Who might still consider using it?
- Mature users who are financially comfortable and understand the credit system
- People who are skeptical by nature and can distinguish between superficial interest and genuine interaction
- Anyone ready to report suspicious behavior immediately and not invest too heavily without verification
Who should probably avoid it?
- Those new to online dating and not accustomed to pay-per-message platforms
- Anyone looking for a platform with guaranteed genuine profiles or a more traditional subscription model
- Users who are risk-averse about financial loss or who’ve been previously targeted by dating scams
Safety Tips If You’re Considering DateMyAge
- Start small: Try a few credits before committing large sums.
- Be skeptical: If someone’s messages seem overly flattering or scripted, take it slow.
- Report profiles: Use any suspicious behavior tool or reach out to support.
- Use secure payment methods: Prefer credit cards or payment methods that offer buyer protection.
- Limit personal info sharing: Avoid sharing phone numbers or financial details until you’re sure someone is real.
Conclusion
DateMyAge.com is not necessarily a fraudulent site in the sense of being a malware or phishing trap — its SSL is valid, and it has been operating for several years. But its business model, combined with a large number of user complaints, suggests that many users feel exploited rather than empowered.
If you’re willing to navigate the pitfalls — the credit system, potential fake profiles, and tricky cancellation processes — there might be something for you here. But if you’re looking for straightforward, real-people interaction without constant financial pressure, there may be better—and safer—alternatives out there.
